I Resolve NOT To Want To Lose Weight

It's that time of year again. Seems like everyone is resolving to lose weight. And some part of me is okay with that, there are probably a lot of people that are unhealthy because of extra weight that is impacting everything from organ function to joint function to their ability to live life as they want to. Those people need to lose weight.

I am not one of those people. I don't say that to gloat, I say that because even though any rational person would look at me and say that I am in great shape, (at least for a woman "of a certain age" who has given birth) I still look in the mirror and think, "hmmmm, when did that happen?" By "that," I mean the fact that my inner thighs touch, my outer thighs are wider than my butt, my breasts are apparently running for cover in my navel and my stomach is still proudly proclaiming "a baby lived here once." Hmmmmm, indeed.

I struggle, every day, with loving my body for the things it can do and not for how closely it resembles what the beauty industry says it should.

Back to it being, "that time of year." While I firmly believe that people need to find a healthy weight and get there, I am terrified of people who are at a healthy weight trying to lose more in order to meet some ridiculous UNREAL standard set by the beauty industry.

In my inbox I received some New Years Resolutions from Sephora, a previously favorite cosmetics store. They offered me some New Years Resolutions, including "I Will Lose Weight" and a promo for some appetite-suppressing, low-cal lip gloss. Okay, first of all, I cannot imagine a stupider product. Does anyone really eat a tube of lip-gloss? But that set aside, I have some serious messaging issues here:

  • You should be so obsessed with your weight that you are even counting calories with lip-gloss.
  • You need to eat less, so this tastes good enough that you won't realize you are not eating food.
  • Whoever you are, we are confident that you either need to lose weight, or are insecure enough about your body that you'll believe us when we tell you that you need to lose weight and will buy this product to ease that fear.

Really, it's the last point that gets me.

Let's look at some statistics provided by National Eating Disorders Association:

  • 10 million women are fighting life-threatening battles with Anorexia and Bulemia.
  • 80% of women report being dissatisfied with their bodies
  • 40% of newly reported cases of Anorexia & Bulemia are in girls 15-19 years old
  • The rise in these cases has been 30% annually since the 1930's
  • 42% of 1st - 3rd grade girls want to be thinner
  • The average American woman is 5'4" tall and weighs 140 pounds. The average American model is 5'11" tall and weighs 117 pounds.

When I look at numbers like that, it is hard for me to come to any conclusion other than that women and girls body image is shaped by media messaging. And that makes media messages - even seemingly stupid and innocent ones like the one from Sephora - really important in shaping not only the bodies but the body image and self-esteem of at least half our population.

That message may have been stupid, but it is part of a national health crisis.

A crisis based, literally, on lies. Because if you know anything about images in the media, you know they are not real. Not even kind of. Luckily, the women at 5 Resolutions, who work tirelessly to battle these media messages have put together a really nice summary of the year in re-touched photos. This great link has several examples of retouched and original photos of celebrities we are all familiar with, as well as the great Dove Video showing the process of being turned from a "regular" person into a super model. I recommend these for anyone - but especially for those of us raising girls.

Look, I do want to lose 5 pounds. Really. But, here's the deal. I'm having a blast in this body exactly how it is. This body - complete with a few extra pounds - has taken me to Mountain tops, finished triathlons, held my daughter, made love to my husband, walked miles with friends and can still put on a fun costume and party all night. This body does not define me, but what I do with it does.

Ironically, I was going to sit down and write a piece about childhood obesity tonight. But I got that inane email from Sephora, and I couldn't ignore it. Even more ironically, that post (which I will probably write soon) will have much of the same messaging.

We need to be healthy. Not too big, not too small. We need to be who we are, not what magazines tell us to be. We need to support each other in our efforts to be healthy, secure and proud of ourselves.

And we sure as hell need to NOT fall for stupid marketing ploys like low-calorie, appetite-suppressing lip gloss.

It's that time of year

It's that time of year again. Seems like everyone is resolving to lose weight. And some part of me is okay with that, there are probably a lot of people that are unhealthy because of extra weight that is impacting everything from organ function to joint function to their ability to live life as they want to. Those people need to lose weight.This dancing girl has lots of dresses to wear during her dancing lessons Dresses Shop For prom dresses, formal dresses, evening gowns, cocktail dresses and more

Investors should invest in

Investors should invest in real estate as the populations is increasing and there would be requirement of land or house for every one. Link building package

The people in gym often

The people in gym often conduct weight reduction programs with diet charts and advise to control the increasing body weight.

thermogenic fat burner

Abdominal fat often is a

Abdominal fat often is a sign of fat around the Heart . Also it can hinder breath as in sleep apnea which can put even more stress on the Heart , not to mention other parts of the body.

how to reduce belly fat

As resistance training

As resistance training athletes, we have a greater need for vitamins & minerals. When we workout and bring blood to our muscles it is important that our blood is full of those essential vitamins & minerals if we want to grow.

natural fat burner pills

I resolve ...

... to simply be healthy, in spril, mind and body.  I love your post and you hit the nail right on the head. 

body insecurity = marketer's dream

wow, Sephora stooped low with the lip gloss campaign! It's insulting and offensive to be marketed to like that. They must assume the buyer is dumb as a rock to think of lip gloss as a diet aid.

Advertisers target people on a subconscious level. Combat this by looking at ads consciously. We can learn (and teach children) about the messages of ad campaigns and how to interpret them. It's a fun lesson and helps "bulletproof" us all against aggressive advertisers. It could also help us interpret art by looking at hidden messages and meanings.

There's an interesting study by a creative director of an ad agency where he points out the 12 advertising formulas designed to trigger consumer response...unless you know what they are! Ha! Here's the study.

Susan

Papergeist

You guys humble me!

Thanks to all of you who have commented here - you humble me. This is a seriously important issue, and one that I wish were not so resonant for so many people. But it is. I'm going to try to respond to some of your specific comments in one fell swoop here:

1. Nasty letter to Sephora. Well, no, because that's not in my nature. I did send them a NOT nasty letter which, after a little back and forth, was sent on to their marketing department. I'm inclined to believe it was an "innocent" mistake (total rookie mistake) by someone who was being funny. Maybe. I hope. But the product is real, and is made by a different company. Me being me, (for better or worse) I suggested that a better way to market fruity lip gloss to smart women would be something along the lines of, "Eat More Fruit, it's healthy for that hot bod of yours. But when you can't grab an apple, grab a tube of...."

2. Marilyn Monroe. Yes. I am often struck by how beautiful most woman are when they are caught off guard - without a lot of makeup and stuff. With real curves and real bodies that look like they do real things in them. Which plays into JenMoon's point about Oprah. She does an extraordinary job of empowering people to feel strong in their skin. And she has had the courage to show us what goes in to making her look how she does when we see her. And she's real. Big, flawed and beautiful because of it. (Not in spite of it.)

3. Photos. Now there's a landmine! Shall we dance? If you click on the link in the post and go to the 5 resolutions page, I'm tickled that they included that bulked up image of Andy Roddick - we see that this is something that plagues all of us. This ridiculous perception that we are not okay just as we are. HOWEVER, you get campaigns like the DOVE campaign for real beauty, and I think there is hope. These guys took the "bull" by the horns and rode it somewhere more positive. It is widely looked at as one of the most successful branding campaigns in history, so I'm waiting for the rest of the world to catch up.

Photo of me? Hmmmm, that's just as complicated. Some of it is simple, most of my pictures of me are on an old computer that isn't currently hooked into anything - some of me rock climbing that are totally impressive looking...

But it also taps into a larger branding question - what image of me does the world want / can it handle / is in the best interest of this company? I went looking through the few photos that I do have in the iPhoto on my computer, and I found a few of me at parties, glass of wine in hand. Is that appropriate? A few at Burning Man in wild outfits, truly celebrating the art that is beauty and life. Is that appropriate? A bunch of me leading girl scout meetings, but there are loads of other kids in those, and that's not legal, unless I get permission from everyone. And several of me all "dressed" up at parties, pearls, lipstick the like. Probably the most appropriate, but totally not what I really look like. (Though does offer a measure of "look, it's not like I hate make-up.....")

I wanted something with a body. Because at the end of it all, that's what we're talking about: People's right & need to feel good in their bodies. Models are seen in bikinis all the time. Dove has huge campaigns of "real" women in bikinis and underwear. It is, indeed, time to claim our bodies. And to look at them, accept them, celebrate them. Yet, it is an undeniable fact that women who "dare" to show their bodies are looked at differently. (Perhaps that's the real issue.)

Even business leaders have bodies. Parents do. Teachers do. Movie stars do. And each of us have many sides - loud, quiet, crazy, reserved, academic, professional, sexual, intelletual - and I look forward to the day when we do not have to hide ANY of them. When being fully human means allowing not only our own full spectrum, but others as well.

We are not there yet. I'm trying to push the envelope as gently as I can. One of my secret missions is to be a major figure in the business world as a fully-fleshed human being, not just an archetype. We'll see how that plays out.

in the mean time, here's another picture. It's "horrid," in a way, it was taken with the camera built into the top of my laptop, no make-up, not even sure if a shower was involved that day. But it's me and my daughter, and I do love it. Alyssa Royse


good on you!

I'm so very tired of anyone telling anyone else what size they SHOULD be. I'm kinda pudgy, kinda flabby and so far I haven't ever had trouble finding people to love me because of these things.
I have never ever been turned down for a date based on my body (that I know of). I think we should all be posting pictures of ourselves in our full glory all the time, to offset the crazy airbrushing false universe portrayed in the media- hell, if you see celeb interviews, even THEY are amazed at how images of them are manipulated!
Technology has come further in manipulating the human form than dieting and exercies ever could, and why would we?! We are all beautiful in our bodies. As long as they function, they're lovely!

I'd love to see a photo spread of REAL women with REAL bodies and healthy self-esteem, to show our daughters, and all women.

 

 

 

 

~~~well behaved women rarely make history.~~~

Good post...new pic needed! ;-)

Srsly...I've seen you.  You can post a full body pic and no one is going to cry.  If you are brave enough to write the post, I think an un-retouched photo of you climbing that mountain, cuddling your cuties, or dancing can stand to make it on this page as well.  Not that the pearl pic isn't cute too but you look like you're going to have dinner with the in-laws (MY in-laws!).

 That said, the post addresses some of the worst issues I have with the magazine industry and the media in general (I love that your link once you follow it includes a retouch of a guy's magazine too; the incredible Hulk treatment!) these days - playing to our fears instead of hopes.  People wonder why Oprah's magazine is such a big seller?  She's playing to hope...not a lot about weight loss or how bad a person in there.  All about healthy eating and how to forgive your mom and what's good to read.  Even if you don't like her, you won't feel bad about yourself as a person afterwards.

 Don't get me started about the lip gloss; I may never be able to shop at Sephora again.  Did you at least write them a nasty or concerned email?  They'll never know you stop shopping somewhere unless you tell them...

Remember when Marilyn Monroe

Remember when Marilyn Monroe was hot? She was what, a size 12? 14?  It's so odd when they take normal people and turn them into stick insects with freaky anime heads.

I'd like to see a natural pic of you! 

Cool Post

I enjoyed this, Alyssa. As a woman who "loves" her body--for what it does, not for what it looks like--I love this post.